Overcast

Overcast

max temp: 15°C

min temp: 12°C

ESTD 1874 Search

The pigs are coming. Find out more about

Pigs Gone Wild

here.

Retail: Lord Myners’ review of Co-operative Group identifies ‘massive failure’ of governance

14:03 14 March 2014

Lord Myners who is conducting a review of of the Co-operative Group

Lord Myners who is conducting a review of of the Co-operative Group's governance and structure.

The Co-operative Group must take urgent steps to reform a “massive failure” of governance or it will go bust, former City minister Lord Myners has warned.

In a damning interim review of the way the group is run, Lord Myners slammed the Co-op’s board for its lack of adequate experience and oversight failings and said he was “deeply troubled by the disdain and lack of respect for the executive team” among some members.

He said members of the board who have been elected from within the Co-op have “simply not been up to their task”.

“The Co-operative Group suffers from acute systemic weaknesses in its governance framework that over many years have gravely damaged the organisation,” he said.

“Unless the group takes urgent steps to reform its governance so that it generates sustainable economic value, it will run out of capital to support its business.”

Lord Myners, who was appointed by the Co-op to conduct the governance review, said he published his findings early after the mutual was thrown back into crisis this week following the controversial resignation of chief executive Euan Sutherland.

Mr Sutherland quit on Monday, claiming the Co-op was “ungovernable” and board members had repeatedly frustrated his efforts for reform.

He took to Facebook to complain that “an individual, or individuals” at the top of the group had deliberately sought to undermine him by revealing details of his £3.66million pay deal to a Sunday newspaper.

Lord Myners, who is also a new board member at the Co-op, heaped praise on Mr Sutherland and his team, saying it was “only due to the exceptional skill and tireless efforts of a new executive team, led by Euan Sutherland, that the group survived”.

But his report lays bare a board that is reluctant to accept change and unsupportive of executive management.

He said: “There is a phrase frequently used in Co-operative Group circles that the executive should be ‘on tap but not on top’,” he revealed.

There is also “acute concern” among Co-op board members and those in the regions and areas over how reform can be achieved while preserving democracy, according to his report. I, however, am confident that the two are fully compatible,” he said.

In an emergency call on Monday following Mr Sutherland’s resignation, the Co-op board agreed to the main recommendation by Lord Myners in his review that it should be abolished in favour of a new “plc” style board including only executive and non-executive directors, responsible for taking commercial decisions. However, the board shake-up still needs to be finalised and agreed by Co-op members.

Lord Myners said previous attempts at governance reform had been largely ignored, but cautioned: “This time, such an outcome will create significant risk of the demise of this organisation.”

The governance issues also need to be resolved before the Co-op brings a new permanent chief executive on board, as the group would fail to attract applications from “best-in-class” retail executives, he said.

Mr Sutherland has been replaced by chief financial officer Richard Pennycook, who has been appointed as interim chief executive. His departure after less than a year at the helm leaves the Co-op without a permanent boss and facing the biggest governance overhaul in its history.

Lord Myners also launched an attack on the group’s elected membership system, that leaves ordinary members with “very little power” and “surprisingly weak constitutional rights”.

“’One member, one vote’ has been a core principle of co-operative ownership, yet at present ordinary members do not have the right to attend annual general meetings or vote to elect or re-elect group board directors,” he said.

Alongside the complete boardroom overhaul, Lord Myners is also recommending that a National Membership Council (NMC) be set up, including employee representatives, to hold the board to account and have powers to ensure the group adheres to co-op values and ethics. His review also said group board directors should be subject to annual election or re-election by all members.

Lord Myners is due to publish his first full report by the end of next month, but said he “found it necessary to go further” in his recommendations after uncovering weaknesses throughout the entire democratic process at the Co-op.

His report also raised concerns over the group’s social goals agenda and called for a full audit of controls over money spent in this area.

Lord Myners was appointed to the board in December and tasked with the independent review after a disastrous year for the Co-op in which its banking arm needed to be rescued following the discovery of a £1.5 billion hole in its finances.

It is now facing a series of investigations into what went wrong, as well as continuing questions over the appointment of disgraced bank chairman Paul Flowers despite a lack of knowledge of the sector. He was later exposed in a newspaper drugs sting.

0 comments

The Teapot at Mcginty's Ipswich. Junk Food cafe run by Mischa Pearson and voulnteers.
Pictured Sarah sharlott, kath gosling, mischa Pearson, Adam Ferguson, Anna engstrom

An award-winning pay-what-you-feel cafe which supports dozens of homeless and vulnerable people in Ipswich has been given just three weeks to find a new base.

Former Seven Resourcing apprentices with Ben Gummer MP, from left, Elliot Frost, Mike Wright, Jade Nunn, Jesse Miller, Ben Gummer and George Owen.

Ipswich-based specialist recruitment agency Seven Resourcing has hosted a visit from the town’s MP, Ben Gummer, to showcase the success of its apprenticeship scheme.

Spending on Eating Out remained robust during April, according to a survey carried out for Greene King.

Britons continued to enjoy eating out during April, according to a new survey, despite reports of growing concern over the strength of the UK economy and the potential impact of a vote to leave the EU in next month’s referendum.

Meeting organised by the Institute of Directors about Suffolks burgeoning film industry. Julien Mery, co-founder of Livid Films and director of Film Suffolk, discussed how the creative community in Suffolk is putting the county on the UK and worlds creative industry map. L-R Sarah Brown, Graham Kill, Julien Mery and Old Jet's Jesse Quin.

A group of executives got to see the creative side of Suffolk’s economy at one of the county’s most popular filmmaking locations.

Oliver Paul, owner of the Suffolk Food Hall, DEFRA Secretary Liz Truss, South Suffolk MP James Cartlidge and Babergh District Councillor Jennie Jenkins meet for an informal meeting on the outcome of the RDPE funding provided for the commercial artisan kitchens in the Cookhouse at the Suffolk Food Hall.

Apprenticeship Levy funding from major supermarket chains and food manufacturers could deliver a boost to skills training for smaller food businesses and farming, a senior Government minister has said during a visit to Suffolk.

Most read

Great Days Out

cover

Click here to view
the Great Days Out
supplement

View

Most commented

HOT JOBS

Show Job Lists

Streetlife

Newsletter Sign Up

Great British Life

Great British Life
MyDate24 MyPhotos24