Green clerical gauleiters are today's Scrooges

SPARE us from trendy clerics!

 

The Church of England has jumped on the green bandwagon, casting those who do not recycle or who dare illuminate their homes with festive lights, as sinners.

 

Dr Rowan Williams, the Archbishop of Canterbury, has even posted his New Year message – God “does not do waste” – on YouTube, allowing people worldwide to upload and share the video clip.

 

“Are we so fixated on keeping up with change that we lose any sense of our need for stability?” he asks.

 

Dr Williams said the need for a sustainable approach also underlines important truths about God and the world. “A lot of the time, we just don't let ourselves think about the future with realism. A culture of vast material waste and emotional short-termism is a culture that is a lot more fragile than it knows.

 

“A life that communicates a bit of what God is like is a life that doesn't give up, that doesn't settle down with a culture of waste and disposability - whether with people, or with things.”

 

Even worse came from the Rt. Rev. Graham James, Bishop of Norwich, who in front of the Queen in Sandringham yesterday condemned people who festoon their homes with Christmas lights for creating “minor ecological disaster zones.”

 

No thought for those to whom dressing their homes gives them pleasure and comfort, and to passers-by with their children who think the lights and decorations are wonderful.

 

I’m all for recycling if your local council – unlike mine, Suffolk Coastal – provides a first class kerbside collection service. But telling all to dim or extinguish Christmas lights is not going to save the planet unless the French, Germans, Italians, Estonians, Americans, Canadians, and Australians etc etc do the same.

 

Incidentally, the Sandringham estate was lit this year with half a mile of coloured lights which normally adorn the Golden Mile at Blackpool.  Presumably, the Bishop of Norwich was not asked to bless them.


posted on 31 December 2007 09:12 by Graham Dines

Comments

31 December 2007 13:59 by Andrew Cann

# re: Green clerical gauleiters are today's Scrooges

Graham

I think the CoE does much good but must agree with you here. We must encourage 'greener' choices not condemn those that do not make them as 'sinners'. They were not sinners yesterday after all or indeed in biblical times.....

Take the feeding of the five thousand for instance. We don't know what happened with the waste from that event do we? Presumably left where it fell.... And were there chemical toilets?

Seriously though whilst there will always be an element of both carrot and stick in promoting greener choices outright condemnation or moralising is not going to be helpful. That path leads to a reactionary future.
We're only going to make it work through consensus and as you hint - across international boundaries that is proving to be difficult enough.
31 December 2007 16:03 by johnB

# re: Green clerical gauleiters are today's Scrooges

The church trying to be hep and with it via YouTube etc. just can't manage it, just as for example classical singers such as Pavarotti just can't sing pop or jazz, much as they think they can. The church waffles on about so called green issues in preference to all the dreadful things going on in the world. And what on earth (or in heaven) is 'emotional short-termism'? And since when does 'a culture' know anything. Dr.Williams should be in parliament where his waffle would fit in extremely well.
05 January 2008 18:04 by John w

# re: Green clerical gauleiters are today's Scrooges

Bless him(Bishop of Norwich) his heart is in the right place but his brain has already ascended.How many tonnes of carbon have been used by vehicles making the journey to church,( quite unnecessary as God is everywhere and makes the Bishop redundant )has he not seen the illuminated signs adorning CoE buildings and the shining crosses that are contributing to the problem all year around and not just at christmas, or has CoE signed up for green electricity bills.Like seasonal lighting these are all small distractions and brighten up our lives,some energy coming from renewable sources anyway
These guys are trying to send a message and doing the christmas PR stuff,trouble is it is non to subtle.
As for making the excuse that conservation is not for us simply because Johhny foreigner will not do it.Are we now followers of every one else not able to take a lead?