Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 15°C

min temp: 9°C

ESTD 1874 Search

Bury St Edmunds: Coroner says West Suffolk Hospital needs to learn lessons following woman’s death

12:00 22 May 2014

Coroner Dr Peter Dean

Coroner Dr Peter Dean


A coroner has said lessons need to be learned by a hospital after the fractured pelvis which contributed to an elderly woman’s death was not diagnosed.

Yesterday, a full inquest with witnesses took place into the death of Else Harvey-Samuel, 89, who had been living at the Martins care home in Bury St Edmunds.

She suffered a fall at the home on February 14 last year and was admitted to West Suffolk Hospital the following day. She passed away there on February 24 after suffering considerable discomfort and pain.

Mrs Harvey-Samuel’s family had had concerns that an X-ray of the pelvis was requested by a clinician as part of further investigations, but not conducted, and this had not been communicated to them.

Concluding the inquest, Coroner Dr Peter Dean said Mrs Harvey-Samuel died from complications following a fall and fractured pelvis contributed to by significant pre-existing natural disease.

He said in terms of lessons to be learned he had three recommendations for West Suffolk Hospital:

•that doctors requesting radiographs or other imaging investigations include sufficient clinical information to explain why it is needed to avoid a request being rejected and also to inform the radiologist;

•in the event of further need for justification for an out-of-hours investigation discussion between a senior clinician and senior radiologist should take place and be documented;

• and in any post untoward incident investigation the system must be satisfactorily robust to establish fully what happened and to take statements from anybody involved near the time of the incident.

Dr Dean said: “None of these three points are intended in any way as criticism of individuals, but clearly a system needs to be in place to ensure patients who present with difficult problems, particularly where the diagnosis is not clear for a variety of reasons, do have the benefit of the best possible system for that patient.”

The inquest heard that had the fractured pelvis been diagnosed an operation would not have been offered anyway as it is not a weight-bearing joint. What diagnosis would have been able to do was allow clinicians to better manage Mrs Harvey-Samuel’s pain and general clinical care, Dr Dean said.

He added he did not think knowing the pelvis was fractured would have alerted the “very tragic” outcome.

An incident report was carried out by Dr James Barrett, consultant radiologist, on May 24, but Dr Dean said had he judged the incident to be “serious” and a serious incident review was then carried out it would have given further insights.

A spokesman for West Suffolk Hospital said: “We would like to take this opportunity to pass on our condolences to Mrs Harvey-Samuel’s family. We will act on the coroner’s recommendations when we receive them.”

1 comment

  • Good luck to Mr Gearing and his ilk who campaign for sensible speed limits and thankyou to EADT for reporting them. Sadly, in Suffolk, these campaigners are knocking their heads against the brick walls of the county and the police who make so much play of keeping us safe.

    Report this comment


    Tuesday, May 27, 2014

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Felixstowe town centre looking busy and vibrant.

Two Suffolk communities have been praised for revitalising their high street “as a unique place for living, working and shopping”.

The boy was riding a scrambler bike (stock image)

Two men are reported to have produced a “firearm and knife” when they allegedly robbed a 13-year-old boy of his scrambler motorbike in Jaywick.

Some of the East of England Co-op team in Woodbridge. Left to right: Emma Harrison, Linda Smith, manager Chris Matthews, Shirley Pierce and Andrea Carretta.

Golden envelopes handed to the first customers through the door of Suffolk newest Co-op store could contain special prizes tomorrow.

Benefit cheat to be sentenced at crown court

A 76-year-old benefit cheat who falsely claimed more than £13,000 over a seven-year period is to be sentenced at Ipswich Crown Court.

A new report has claimed that laws targeting anti-social behaviour in public spaces are causing dog owners

Animal campaigners have lobbied the government over laws banning dogs from public spaces – a week before district leaders discuss using the rules to extend restrictions on a Suffolk beach.

File photo dated 10/09/14 of a GP writing a prescription, as patients who do not visit their GP for five years face being axed from their doctor's surgery under plans being rolled out across England. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Issue date: Wednesday July 20, 2016. NHS England has employed private company Capita to lead the drive - known as

MPs have highlighted Suffolk’s £1m paracetamol price tag which is adding to an “unsustainable” drugs bill in the county.

Christopher Revens after surgery with his Ipswich Town card

An Ipswich Town season ticket holder and lifelong Suffolk resident is already back at work just nine weeks after pioneering new surgery removed a large brain tumour.

Most read

Great Days Out


Click here to view
the Great Days Out


Most commented


Show Job Lists


Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

MyDate24 MyPhotos24