Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 16°C

min temp: 7°C

ESTD 1874 Search

WIN A NEW HYUNDAI i10 - See the EADT on June 8 for full details

Bury St Edmunds: Local views ignored as school reorganisation goes ahead – claim

10:42 13 March 2014

The Howard Middle School will disappear under the SOR proposals - the site will be used for a new primary school.

The Howard Middle School will disappear under the SOR proposals - the site will be used for a new primary school.

The needs of students and parents at one of the most seriously-affected schools in Bury St Edmunds were ignored when the county council went ahead with the latest stage of its education reform, councillors have heard.

shares

Members of Suffolk County Council’s scrutiny committee decided against referring the latest phase of the Schools’ Organisation Review (SOR) process back to the authority’s cabinet following last month’s decision to go ahead.

But the decision was only made on the casting vote of committee chair Jane Storey after impassioned pleas to reconsider the decision.

The review will see the current three-tier school system in Bury St Edmunds replaced with a two-tier system by September 2016

Before the debate started Sue George, chair of governors of the Howard Middle School which would cease to exist if the proposals are approved, said the vast majority of parents with children at the school were opposed to the changes.

The school serves large housing estates, and instead of going to the nearby County Upper School they faced a long trek to a new school at Moreton Hall.

Parents were not happy with this, and felt their concerns had been ignored by those planning the changes.

She was backed up by fellow governor Helen Stacey, who said: “County Upper is just across the road and is in easy walk for the children in this part of the town. If this goes ahead, they will be bussed three miles to Moreton Hall.”

The scrutiny committee looked at whether cabinet had enough information to make the decision to go ahead with the SOR when it met on February 25.

On that day it approved the publication of statutory notices proposing changes in the Bury St Edmunds area – and to recommended that the government develop a new high school at Moreton Hall.

There is now a further period of consultation before the final orders are put into action. The proposal is that the changes would start in September next year and would be completed by September 2016.

The call-in was led by Labour education spokeswoman Sonia Barker, who said when the issue had been discussed at cabinet not enough weight was given to the concerns of those who would be most directly affected by the decision – the parents and governors linked to the schools that would be shaken up in the review.

She said: “Suffolk County Council’s cabinet should reconsider its decision on the Bury St Edmunds’ SOR until there is sound weighted evidence.”

Her Labour colleague Sandra Gage said the most important people to consider were the students currently at the affected schools.

However cabinet member with responsibilty for education Lisa Chambers said it was vital to include parents of younger children in the debate – because their education would be determined by the decisions made.

The committee voted along party lines when it came to the vote – six Conservatives voted to allow the decision to stand and the six opposition councillors voted for it to be reconsidered.

Chair Jane Storey – the former Conservative deputy leader on the authority – used her casting vote to allow the decision to stand.

Ms Barker said: “The decision taken by the SCC scrutiny committee in response to the call in is symptomatic of the approach taken by this council. Conservative members of the committee were only voting on party lines, not on the evidence presented”.

Mrs Chambers said: “Today’s meeting was an opportunity for us to demonstrate, again, the extremely thorough way in which we have consulted on, and gone about, the process of school reorganisation in Bury St Edmunds.

“This confirms that we have taken all the appropriate actions to ensure a coherent set of proposals are put forward for public consultation.”

shares

1 comment

  • The Chair of the Scrutiny Committee is none other than the same Conservative councillor who only last year was a member of the Cabinet who voted to close the middle schools in Stowmarket & Stowupland. Hardly impartial is she? This decision should have been referred to an independent school's adjudicator because, clearly, this is now a political football where Suffolk County Council have a point to prove whatever the cost.....oh wait the cost is our children's damaged life chances!

    Report this comment

    MDavies

    Thursday, March 13, 2014

Crowds enjoyed the scorching sunshine on the first day of the Suffolk Show 2015.

The 184th Suffolk Show has been declared a “feast of excitement” by director Bill Baker.

UKIP MP Douglas Carswell is driven away in a police van for his own safety as he gets caught up in the anti-austerity protest in Westminster, central London, as protesters mark their opposition to measures set out in the Queen's Speech, following the State Opening of Parliament. Photo: Yui Mok/PA Wire

Clacton’s UKIP MP had to be protected by police in London after being confronted by protestors.

Police have closed the road

A motorcyclist has died after a crash on the A120 at Wix.

The Suffolk Young Farmers Tug of War at the Suffolk Show.

Having lived in the county for nearly 19 years, when telling people I had never been to the Suffolk Show, I was always given a surprised response.

Beautiful day for the first day of the Suffolk show

Town meets country with style and substance as Trinity Park basks in glorious spring sunshine. Lynne Mortimer reports on day one at the Suffolk Show.

Crowds enjoyed the scorching sunshine on the first day of the Suffolk Show 2015.
Hayden and Sienna Cawston in the beach area.

See your photos from day one of the Suffolk Show at Trinity Park today.

The mascots race at the Suffolk Show in the Presidents Ring.

Tractor Boy has spoken of his “regret” after finishing third in the Mascot Derby.

Glenn Williamson, from Williamson Partnership, will be featured on Homes Under the Hammer with a flat he has renovated in Ipswich.

An Ipswich businessman is to appear on the BBC show Homes under the Hammer after he increased the value of a property by £100,000.

Queen Elizabeth II and The Duke of Edinburgh leave Buckingham Palace, London, as the royal procession makes its way along The Mall ahead of the State Opening of Parliament. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Wednesday May 27, 2015. See PA story POLITICS Speech. Photo credit should read: Yui Mok/PA Wire

David Cameron said he aims to ensure the recovery reaches every part of the country – including the East of England – as the Queen delivered his One Nation agenda for the coming parliament.

John Dugmore of The Suffolk Chamber of Commerce

Prime Minister David Cameron has repeated his government’s pledges to invest in East Anglia’s infrastructure as the debate on the Queen’s Speech gets under way.

Most read

Most commented

Topic pages