max temp: 21°C

min temp: 12°C


East Anglia: MP’s anger at region’s rail subsidies

PUBLISHED: 18:00 07 September 2012 | UPDATED: 18:11 07 September 2012

Ben Gummer MP at Ipswich Railway Station

Ben Gummer MP at Ipswich Railway Station


A SUFFOLK MP has hit out at the government for its use of the region’s rail travellers’ fares to subsidise franchises in other parts of the country.

Figures obtained by Ipswich MP Ben Gummer have revealed the extent of East Anglian rail passengers’ “unknowing generosity” to other rail companies.

Between April 2010 and April 2011, the last year for which figures are available, the region’s rail users subsidised rail companies across the UK by £108.9 million.

This is set to increase by 166% by the 2013-2014 financial year, to £181 million.

Mr Gummer said the figures showed that someone buying an annual season ticket in 2011 for £5,300 donated £1611.61 to other rail companies.

He said East Anglia needed the investment far more than many of the regions it is subsidising and it was “time the Government gave us our money back”.

He said: “Rail travellers in Ipswich and the rest of the eastern region will rightly want to know why so much of the money they spend on tickets is given to loss-making companies elsewhere when we do not get badly needed investment in our own infrastructure and rolling stock in return. East Anglia needs this investment far more than many of the regions it is subsidising.

“How can it be right that over £1,600 from every annual season ticket from Ipswich to London in 2010-2011 was spent elsewhere when our trains are older than those of all but four of the 19 other train operating companies?

“How can it be that last year the London Midland train company received 3.6 pence for every passenger kilometre travelled when their trains are on average 14 years younger than ours? “How can the government explain why it is so generous with East Anglian rail users’ money when our own trains are some of the most overcrowded in the country?”

He added: “I know that this is a formula inherited by the government but that is no excuse for allowing it to stand. Every year the sums we pay increase.

“Ministers need to put this right when they negotiate new franchises with train operating companies.”

A spokesman for the Department for Transport said fares revenues from the Greater Anglia franchise contributed to funding a “fair and affordable” rail service for all.

He said: “If we tried to introduce a self sufficient system of funding, passengers for Greater Anglia would lose out on future improvements as they would need to contribute more towards infrastructure operations maintenance and renewal costs.

“Improvements to our national rail network, such as the new high capacity freight route for Felixstowe and other East Coast ports and work which could improve services between Cambridge, Kings Lynn and Norwich announced in July are only possible through tax payer and fare payer contributions at a national level.”


  • So do we understand then after reading the DoT spokesmans comments that major investment that will improve the ancient rolling stock is just around the corner? Been commuting on the trains for about 10 years and apart from getting the cast off trains and coaches from WCML when that gets a regular update the only improvement I've seen has been a new footbridge built at Ipswich - and they even built that the wrong way round!!

    Report this comment


    Friday, September 7, 2012

  • Why isn't there a national fare policy so that all fares are based on defined criteria; distance travelled, time of day, service type (express etc.)? Is this down to competition? If so why does the tax payer provide additional funds and why is there a postcode lottery on fare premiums? Perhaps all our local MPs can explain why it has taken their party so long to identify this problem and let us know how long before we can expect to be treated farely (pun intended).

    Report this comment


    Friday, September 7, 2012

  • Why has Ben Gummer M.P. suddenly raised the question of a stealth tax on Greater Anglia passengers when this information has been in the public domain for the last eight years. To anyone who cared to study the Department for Transport press releases regarding both the National Express East Anglia and Abellio Greater Anglia franchises it was blindingly obvious that they both won the franchise by promising (bribing) the DfT with shed loads of money, to be taken from passengers. Had NEx East Anglia served the full term of it's 10 year franchise they would have paid the Government roughly £750,000,000 taken from East Anglian passengers. Abellio are currenly paying roughly £475,000 per day to the Government. If Mr Gummer failed to see this until now then he has been failing his travelling constituents big time.

    Report this comment


    Saturday, September 8, 2012

  • Well done Ben Gummer for identifying this. Now, please make sure that you follow through and ensure we're not fleeced for any longer than we need to be.

    Report this comment


    Friday, September 7, 2012

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

South Suffolk is a parliamentary seat that was formed in 1983 and has always looked like safe Conservative territory – even during the high-water mark of Blairite New Labour.

The terror threat level is being increased from severe to critical – indicating a further attack is imminent – after the deadly Manchester Arena bombing.

A support worker at sheltered housing in Felixstowe had to move jobs and suffered from PTSD (Post Traumatic Stress Disorder) after a drunk resident ran past her brandishing a knife, a court has heard.

The parents and sister of a Weeley man killed during the Bataclan massacre in Paris two years ago have spoken of their “unspeakable sadness” after last night’s Manchester Arena bombing.

Two new low-cost retail stores are coming to Bury St Edmunds, as a long redundant site is brought back into use.

The devastated mother of a teenage girl killed in a crash on the A47 in Suffolk has paid tribute to her daughter, who she has described as being “beautiful inside and out”.

The full list of award winners, including glory for Suffolk and North Essex, was unveiled at the Chelsea Flower Show, today.

Most read

Eating Out in the Broads


Click here to view
the Eating Out


Visit the Broads


Click here to view
the Visit the Broads


Show Job Lists

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter
MyDate24 MyPhotos24