Overcast

Overcast

max temp: 13°C

min temp: 12°C

ESTD 1874 Search

East Anglia: Long term solution needed to tackle effects of extreme weather, says enviornment secretary

17:46 11 February 2014

Lord Deben, John Gummer, stands in a field near his Winston home

Lord Deben, John Gummer, stands in a field near his Winston home

Successive governments have failed to make the UK more resilient to floods with a Whitehall shake up needed as extreme weather becomes more frequent, former Environment Secretary Lord Deben has said.

shares

The chair of the Committee on Climate Change (CCC) hit out at the Westminster “blame game” after Tory ministers waded in over the future of Lord Smith.

Defending the under-fire chairman of the Environment Agency, former Suffolk Coastal MP John Gummer said the Labour peer had been a good boss of the quango.

But said that going forward planning and flood defences should be brought under one roof as there were “too many fingers in the pie”.

“We need a long term plan. There should be no short term blame. These floods have not been so disastrous because of a particular minister, because of a particular agency, because of not dredging the rivers. All that is nonsense. The reason why the floods have been so bad is because we have not had a long term plan where every year we have made ourselves more resilient.”

He said Mr Pickles’ Department for Communities and Local Government should lose responsibility for planning, with a new minister for planning and land use installed at Defra responsible for “long term resilience”.

He said Defra would be responsible for coastal protection and for the role of Local Authorities and the Environment Agency, with local authorities like Suffolk Coastal used as the “agent”.

“In the department you would have the expertise, but the actual business of dealing with it would be the Local Authority.”

“If you take Suffolk. There are bits of (coastal protection) run by Suffolk Coastal District Council, and bits run by the Environment Agency. It doesn’t make sense.”

He hit out at suggestions that money for flood-hit communities should be taken from the international aid budget, saying: “The idea that you would steal from people who are starving, have no hospitals, the idea that you would steal from them in order to provide what you should be providing is an absolute outrage. It is absolutely disgraceful.”

“We have to pay for it ourselves. There are other things you can take the money from, you have to do it.

“One of the things. We might have to ask if we can find ways of using money from planning to alleviate this. There are lots of ways you can do this. The idea of stealing money from the poorest is an affront.”

He also said that changes needed to be made to the way the “cost benefit analysis” was made over whether to replace sea defences.

“I think there is a balance. I’m not suggesting we defend every single inch. We need to feed our people. I think agricultural land has got to be more valuable in that cost benefit analysis. It is going to be more important for feeding people.”

He also said that landowners should be much freer to defend their land themselves and that regulations which prevented farmers from defending their land should be looked at.

Related articles

shares

8 comments

  • After the fourth year of wet and windy weather in succession, one's head has to be especially deep in the sand toclaim its random. To then quote quantitative measurements, when the winter has not finished make this a wild unsubstantiated and unscientific claim, Roy. John Gummer is partially right, this is not an issue to play party politics with, the right part, and if he wants to find money, not from us as he says, but from planning, which is us, nice trick, then he should look no further than to the insurance giants who already are sending out bills for higher premiums. It is us who pay these bills already, so we, John, are paying for this disaster as we have paid for the last one, so what does that make this article? Those who annually raise our premiums have a vested interest in active alleviation of flooding and sea defences, and they can use their own money and get it back from tidal energy schemes.

    Report this comment

    ingo wagenknecht

    Wednesday, February 12, 2014

  • sorry, once again the EDP's spinning software has created a triple post.

    Report this comment

    ingo wagenknecht

    Thursday, February 13, 2014

  • The notion that extreme weather is becoming more frequent is unsupported by any quantitative measurements,both globally and in the UK. The fact that some people sincerely believe that it has is a curious psychological phenomenon akin to mass delusion or religious belief.

    Report this comment

    Roy Everett

    Wednesday, February 12, 2014

  • After the fourth year of wet and windy weather in succession, one's head has to be especially deep in the sand toclaim its random. To then quote quantitative measurements, when the winter has not finished make this a wild unsubstantiated and unscientific claim, Roy. John Gummer is partially right, this is not an issue to play party politics with, the right part, and if he wants to find money, not from us as he says, but from planning, which is us, nice trick, then he should look no further than to the insurance giants who already are sending out bills for higher premiums. It is us who pay these bills already, so we, John, are paying for this disaster as we have paid for the last one, so what does that make this article? Those who annually raise our premiums have a vested interest in active alleviation of flooding and sea defences, and they can use their own money and get it back from tidal energy schemes.

    Report this comment

    ingo wagenknecht

    Wednesday, February 12, 2014

  • Who would have thought it. Another government bloke spouting the blindingly obvious. Got news for him. People have been using tried and tested methods to keep the weather under control since medieval times in our part of Norfolk. It's only when governments intervene and stop keeping to their part of the bargain that problems begin.

    Report this comment

    alecto

    Wednesday, February 12, 2014

  • After the fourth year of wet and windy weather in succession, one's head has to be especially deep in the sand toclaim its random. To then quote quantitative measurements, when the winter has not finished make this a wild unsubstantiated and unscientific claim, Roy. John Gummer is partially right, this is not an issue to play party politics with, the right part, and if he wants to find money, not from us as he says, but from planning, which is us, nice trick, then he should look no further than to the insurance giants who already are sending out bills for higher premiums. It is us who pay these bills already, so we, John, are paying for this disaster as we have paid for the last one, so what does that make this article? Those who annually raise our premiums have a vested interest in active alleviation of flooding and sea defences, and they can use their own money and get it back from tidal energy schemes.

    Report this comment

    ingo wagenknecht

    Wednesday, February 12, 2014

  • Lord Deben is quite right !, the lack of long term investment in our infrastructure is all too apparent !, however I would have to ask why when John Gummer was in the cabinet with 'sell off' everything thatcher did he NOT do more then ?, all the tories have ever done to this country is 'cream' off the profits at the top !!, which of course we all know is still happening today !, 'spouting' is one thing ! ACTION is achievement !!

    Report this comment

    freedomf

    Wednesday, February 12, 2014

  • There can be no confidence in the government until the elected Environment Secretary is sacked.A climate change denier should not be in charge.

    Report this comment

    Peter Watson

    Wednesday, February 12, 2014

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Essex fire crews attended

Firefighters in Essex have been called to a blaze at an art warehouse in Colchester this evening.

London Road North in Lowestoft has been cordoned off by emergency services.

Emergency services have descended on the centre of Lowestoft following an incident this afternoon.

Shotley wins Village of the Year.

Shotley has been announced the winner of the annual Suffolk Village of the Year competition.

Firefighters attended the incident

Emergency services were called to a crash on the A14 near Coddenham this afternoon.

It won't be the real thing, sadly, but there is an Abba tribute in Colchester this weekend

Brave the September weather this weekend and treat family and friends to a day out in East Anglia. Unsure where to go? Here are 10 events you shouldn’t miss:

The scene of a fire at Exning Primary School. Headteacher, James Clark.

Two members of the public tried to stop the blaze at Exning Primary School before the fire brigade arrived.

Ronald Chisnall

An 89-year-old widower who sexually assaulted two schoolgirls at his Ipswich home has been jailed for 34 months.

Fire crews at the scene of a fire behind the former Burton's factory in Ipswich Waterfront

Firefighters have been called to a fire at the former Burtons factory on Ipswich Waterfront.

Jonathan Dotchin, Kezi Mellen UCS LGBT+ society with Valerie Jarvis of Theta Cafe with some of the items collected for Calais refugees.

Members of a university Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender (LGBT) society have launched a collection for refugees in Calais.

The A14

Emergency teams worked to release a man trapped in his car after it overturned on the A14.

Most read

Most commented

Topic pages