Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 10°C

min temp: 9°C

ESTD 1874 Search

Education matters: Geoff Barton discusses a think tank’s criticism of Ofsted

11:10 19 March 2014

Geoff Barton

Geoff Barton


Geoff Barton responds to criticism of Ofsted published by the Policy Exchange think tank

I did try – honest. I made a promise to myself that this month I would write an education article that didn’t mention Ofsted.

Instead, I thought I’d write about real education – the stuff that goes on in school classrooms day after day, and which isn’t simply a performance designed to satisfy the tick-box mentality of some passing inspector.

So I did everything I could not even to think about Ofsted.

It’s a bit like that scene in the BBC’s classic series The Singing Detective. Suffering from a chronic skin condition, Michael Gambon has to use every bit of mental self-discipline he can muster in order not to get excited as a nurse rubs lotion into his flaking flesh.

He brings to mind every tedious, disconnected image he can to keep his thoughts away from thinking about what the nurse may be doing to him: “A Welsh male-voice choir, wage rates in Peru, Elvis’ birthday ... “ he repeats to himself, striving manfully to distract himself.

I seem to recall that in an act of utter desperation he finally imagines Tony Blackburn.

So we all begin with good intentions. Then reality kicks in. And it’s proving harder to be Ofsted-free than I had hoped.

Because on Monday this week, the right-leaning think-tank established a few years ago by Michael Gove published a policy document suggesting that Ofsted isn’t fit for purpose.

That thought alone sent the teacher-based margins of Twitter into a kind of gleeful meltdown.

The Policy Exchange report is called ‘Watching the Watchmen’ and it calls for radical overhaul of Ofsted. Inspectors, it says, are too inconsistent; they cost too much; too many don’t have appropriate experience or qualifications; and, crucially, lesson observations don’t really tell us about the quality of teaching. They should therefore be scrapped.

All of this – in a thoroughly readable and well-argued pamphlet – was more than we might expect on a March Monday morning.

No more inspections of lessons? No wonder the teachers loved it.

But I’m not sure that most parents will agree with that recommendation.


A few years back at our school we had a pretty bland Ofsted inspection. It felt to us that anything we showed the lead inspector – lessons, sport, music, a fabulous art exhibition – was seen as a distraction.

You sensed that really the inspector just wanted to be back in an office, gazing at the flickering screen of his laptop, and probing another page of interminable figures.

After he finally delivered his verdict on our school, I said something I probably shouldn’t done: “You might as well have stayed at home and phoned this in.”

That’s what it felt like – as if everything the inspector wanted to say about the school could be lifted from a desktop exercise looking at results. The inspection didn’t say much more than you could read in the performance tables.

Now, I believe that schools are about much more than numbers on an Excel page. Of course results and test scores count. But so do other things – relationships, courtesy, behaviour, the crucial extra-curricular provision.

I’d never send my own children to a school that didn’t have an orchestra or debating society or science club; where the head was never seen on the corridors; or where lunchtimes resembled the OK Corral.

That’s because schools, for me, are about the older generation passing on our values and beliefs and expectations to the younger generation.

And if inspection is designed to help us to improve our schools, I can’t imagine why we wouldn’t want inspectors looking at our core business – visiting classrooms, noting the relationships, seeing teachers at work. This is where you see the lifeblood of any school.

So I agree with Policy Exchange that Ofsted is looking increasingly dysfunctional. It’s not clear that all the money and endless tinkering has led to genuine impact in schools. Instead, in too many, it has generated a climate of fear.

But let’s not therefore reduce inspections to something even more mechanistic and data-driven than it already is.

A good inspector would surely think it unthinkable not to be visiting classrooms and seeing how the school’s end-results are generated. A good headteacher is likely to feel the same.

If we’re serious about overhauling Ofsted, then we should expect it to value things that are hard to measure, and not just catalogue those things easily dissected, quantified and served up on yet another soulless spreadsheet.


Sixth Form joke:

What do we want? More surrealism. When do we want it? Dolphin.

1 comment

  • Two points: 1) The report doesn't say (or suggest) that inspectors shouldn't visit classrooms, just that they should be prevented from the hogwash of making up meaningless data under the guise of 'grading' lessons. 2) It is the job of school leaders to ensure those thing we value are in place and performing as we would wish. Why would we want inspectors do that job for us? Their role ought to be confined to holding head teachers to account on how well they know their school. Thanks, DD

    Report this comment

    David Didau

    Wednesday, March 19, 2014

Tributes have been paid to 31-year-old Lee Pennycuick who died on Friday

The father of a popular Sunday league football player who died suddenly at the age of 31 has described his caring son as someone who would never walk by when others needed help.

Lily Alexander, aged 4, with Dad Judge Dredd from Bury St Edmunds
- Mark Westley Photography

Stormtroopers marched the streets of Bury St Edmunds this weekend as Moyse’s Hall unveiled its acclaimed annual science fiction exhibition.

Ivy Pound at Sudbury Cancer Reasearch UK shop
with buskers who have won an award,  Joe Snell ( left ) and Toby Halls 

Teenage heroes Joe Snell and Toby Halls discovered yesterday they will get the chance to record at the world-famous Maida Vale music studios in London after winning a BBC Radio 1 Teen Hero Award.

Celebrate Halloween at events across Suffolk.

It’s nearly Halloween and there is a variety of events across Suffolk this half term to keep your little monsters entertained no matter what their age.

A house fire in Kirby Cross is believed to have started in a tumble dryer

Firefighters tackled a house fire in Kirby Cross this afternoon.

Magistrates' Court in Ipswich

A disqualified motorist banned for a drink-drive related offence was caught driving again while nearly four-and-a-half times the limit within two hours of his conviction.

Police were deployed to the scene

An armed police officer was called to Kesgrave as a safety precaution after a report was received of an injured dog today.

Most read

Great Days Out


Click here to view
the Great Days Out


Show Job Lists

Don't miss


Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

MyDate24 MyPhotos24