max temp: 15°C

min temp: 15°C

ESTD 1874 Search

Framlingham: College headmaster calls for the Government to “improve” state schools to rival independents

09:03 07 July 2014

Paul Taylor, headmaster at Framlingham College

Paul Taylor, headmaster at Framlingham College

The headteacher of a top public college has called on the education secretary to focus on improving state schools so that they become “genuine, viable alternatives” to independents.


Paul Taylor, headmaster at Framlingham College, was speaking at Speech Day on Saturday when he made the comments.

“There are those out there at the moment – it seems on all sides of the political and social spectrum – that seem determined to undermine the excellence that is represented by so many schools in the independent sector,” he said.

“And before I go on let me stress that no one, by the way, is suggesting that such excellence is the exclusive preserve of the independent sector.

“However, cheap jibes are the currency of the current political marketplace, and schools such as ours are the easy target, with such attacks in my view also threatening by implication so many of the principles of the free, open society that we all celebrate.”

His view could be seen as a response to the secretary of state for education, Michael Gove’s, call for independent schools to be inspected by Ofsted, the current state regulator. Private schools are reviewed by the Independent Schools Inspectorate (ISI).

Mr Taylor said: “I for one, however, will refuse to apologise for pursuing excellence, diversity and breadth in education, or for the emphasis that we place on the values that underpin a decent community and society.

“Surely the aim should be to level up, not down, and I just can’t fathom any policy that deliberately erodes known areas of excellence in order to ensure perceived – and often superficial – equality (and we can all think of national regimes that have tried just this in living memory: it doesn’t work).

“A better route, surely, is for any education secretary to improve the critical mass of schools in the maintained sector to the extent that they become genuine, viable alternatives to independent schools: that is what choice (a critical word here) is all about.”

State schools are currently given an overall rating on a four-point scale – outstanding, good, requires improvement and inadequate.

Headteachers can be sacked and schools converted to into independent academies under new leadership if inspectors find failings. ISI, in comparison, does not provide a single overall judgment but instead assigns scores to all elements of school life such as the quality of leadership and management and teaching.


1 comment

  • I don't suppose that there is anyone who would not like to see Maintained schools perform as well as, or better than, Private schools. However, I see that the basic per pupil Dedicated Schools Grant (DSG) for Suffolk for 2014-2015 is £4241.49. On the other hand, Framlingham's website gives the annual fees for 2013-4 as £17,372 for day pupils, and £27,029 for boarders i.e. the day fee is more than 4 times the DSG. This may in part explain the problems (not always insuperable) in matching the performance of these 2 types of school. Although not directly relevant to this discussion, there are some remarkable differences in DSG in different LAs across the country; London, of course, gets the lion's share.

    Report this comment

    T Doff

    Monday, July 7, 2014

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

The area in Clarkson Street where two gangs fought on September 23

An Ipswich mother-of-two has told of how she was left terrified after getting caught up in the middle of fighting between groups of young men wielding bricks, lumps of wood and an axe.

David Acton, Hannah Hutch and Patti Love in Jane Wenham-The Witch of Walkern, which is touring Suffolk and Essex

A leading Suffolk private school has cancelled a play by an Oscar-winning and National Theatre-sponsored playwright because of fears about bad language and its subject matter which covers child abuse.

Sharon Halls and Daniel Compton's baby, Evie

The mother of a premature baby born 12 weeks early in the Dominican Republic has said they are not expecting to travel home before December.

Talented golfer William Turner, 18,  from Shoeburyness

A teenager who has been sentenced for causing the death of his best-friend will live with his actions “forever”.

Burst water main at Southway, Colchester, October 5. Picture: Jeremy Warren

A burst water main is causing gridlock in central Colchester.

Volunteers and members of the Synergy Cafe in Hadleigh. Holding the cheque are, from left, Suffolk County councillor Sarah Stamp, Andrea Pittock from Suffolk Community Foundation and Richard Whiting, mayor of Hadleigh

Cafes in Suffolk which support people with dementia and their families have won a £10,000 grant to improve the service.

The crash happened on the A14 westbound between Stowmarket and Woolpit.

Motorists have escaped injury during two crashes on the A14 today.

Needham Market train station. All train have been cancelled on the Cambridge to Ipswich line after an incident.

Blocked lines at Needham Market, closed after a body was found on the tracks close to the railway station, have been re-opened.

The scene of a fire at Exning Primary School. Headteacher, James Clark.

Two teenage girls have been charged with arson following a fire at Exning Primary School in September.

Staff at Sainsbury's in Bury take part in a flashmob charity Zumbathon

A Zumba flashmob caught customers at Sainsbury’s in Bury St Edmunds by surprise yesterday.

Most read

Most commented

Topic pages