Overcast

Overcast

max temp: 9°C

min temp: 5°C

ESTD 1874 Search

Orford: Hotel inspector Ruth Watson’s legal challenge over hygiene rating at The Crown and Castle

06:00 04 January 2013

Ruth Watson, star of The Hotel Inspector, has launched a legal challenge over a hygiene rating for her hotel

Ruth Watson, star of The Hotel Inspector, has launched a legal challenge over a hygiene rating for her hotel

A SUFFOLK food writer and broadcaster has launched a legal challenge after inspectors raised concerns about hygiene at her hotel.

shares

Ruth Watson, former star of The Hotel Inspector on Channel 5, hit out after The Crown and Castle in Orford was given a one-out-of-five rating for food hygiene. This means “major improvement necessary”.

It has prompted Mrs Watson, who co-owns the hotel with her husband David, to begin the process to get a judicial review of the decision.

She presented three series of The Hotel Inspector giving tips and advice to struggling hoteliers in a bid to turn their fortunes around.

Suffolk Coastal District Council, who carried out the inspection on November 26, said as a result of the rating certain dishes were removed from the menu. Changes were also made to the layout of the kitchen and how food was handled.

Mrs Watson, who used to run the Fox and Goose in Fressingfield, and Hintlesham Hall, said in a statement: “We strongly disagree with the score we have received from the environmental health officer for Suffolk Coastal District Council, removing our previous maximum score under the scheme. To validate our view we have taken independent advice from one of the UK’s leading food safety experts. He has carried out his own assessment of the EHO’s report and firmly believes that it neither follows, nor accurately reflects, Food Standard Agency guidelines.

“As someone who has worked in the hospitality industry for nearly 30 years, I fully accept there is always room for minor improvements. However part of the problem appears to be that the boundary between taking food safety very seriously, as we always do, and being allowed to cook top quality local ingredients in the way our customers want, is being irrevocably blurred.

“We have made every effort to resolve our dispute with the food safety team as swiftly and amicably as possible, but remain unable to agree with their approach, and so we have commenced the first stage of a judicial review action to allow a court to determine the fairness of the inspection and the rating.”

A spokesman for SCDC, referring to the Orford inspection, said: “The appeal against the rating considered fully the independent advice sought by the Crown and Castle. Our decision to confirm the rating was based firmly on the national guidelines set by the Food Standards Agency and we also took independent advice. We believe that our decision was a correct one and will defend it strongly if it is legally challenged.”

The 21-bedroom Crown and Castle, which is co-owned by the Watsons and Tim Sunderland, calls itself more of a “restaurant with rooms” than a hotel.

The venue says its restaurant, called the Trinity, is a lively bistro serving “decent, unpretentious food”.

The controversy in Orford comes after The Angel Hotel in Bury St Edmunds threatened legal action after it was listed as a zero-star establishment on the Food Standard Agency’s website last year. It was re-inspected on December 19 and rated “generally satisfactory” with three stars.

shares

8 comments

  • Pompous woman. Bluff`s been called. Good.

    Report this comment

    Mad Brewer

    Friday, January 4, 2013

  • Pompous woman. Bluff`s been called. Good.

    Report this comment

    Mad Brewer

    Friday, January 4, 2013

  • Not allowed to comment. The places with the prettiest tables generally have the dirtiest kitchens. Ms Watson is a very arrogant person.

    Report this comment

    Mad Brewer

    Friday, January 4, 2013

  • I live in orford and the wages they pay in that pub are disgraceful. Im not suprised that they only got one star. That Ruth Watson should be ashamed... I have heard that it isn't a nice place to work or go for a meal.

    Report this comment

    C.W

    Friday, January 4, 2013

  • What`s "nice" got to do with truth, Mr. Taylor? Dooont rark the booot, they`re parsh fook?? Grow up. Stop tugging your forelock. Dumbcluck.

    Report this comment

    Mad Brewer

    Sunday, January 6, 2013

  • Pompous woman. Bluff`s been called. Good.

    Report this comment

    Mad Brewer

    Friday, January 4, 2013

  • Sorry for triplicate. Blame Archant. It`s about time some of these chancers were "outed".

    Report this comment

    Mad Brewer

    Friday, January 4, 2013

  • that is not very nice to be judging some one is it .

    Report this comment

    john taylor

    Saturday, January 5, 2013

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Strawberry Stores in Sudbury was hit by an armed robber

An 18-year-old man was arrested in Sudbury following an armed robbery at a convenience store in the town this afternoon.

The land on Church Lane, Claydon.

Proposals for a travellers’ site to the edge of a Suffolk village have been refused by the planning authority.

Essex Police escort a delegation from the Saudi embassy during a visit to Salary Brook in Greenstead, Colchester, to see the scene where Nahid Almanea was killed last June.

Detectives investigating the murder of Nahid Almanea met with officials from the Kingdom Saudi Arabia (KSA) in Colchester today.

Shirley Ison may have made a fatal error which caused her car to collide with a tree

Driver error is believed to be the cause of a road accident in which a woman was killed, it was ruled this week.

Easter fun at Kesgrave Library. Tabitha and Sebastion Degiorgio.

Eggs – chocolate and real ones – were on everyone’s minds as a library held a family event to mark the Easter season.

Extra trains for ITFC Fans

Extra train services have been arranged for Ipswich Town fans on Good Friday.

Hagon pleaded guilty to a charge of causing serious injury by dangerous driving and was sentenced at Chelmsford Crown Court on Tuesday, March 31 to two years and eight months imprisonment and disqualified from driving for five years, after which he must take an extended test, Essex Police said.

A driver has been jailed for two years and eight months following a serious collision in High Garrett, near Braintree.

Planners have refused homes on vacant land at Felixstowe's Haven Exchange site.

Proposals for 61 homes near the Port of Felixstowe have been refused because of the need to keep as much employment land available as possible.

Chelmsford Crown Court

A woman has been left permanently disabled after a driver who had taken a cocktail of drink and drugs smashed into her car.

Ian (L to R) and Debbi Tayler along with Tim Cocker standing with the rubbish they have collected from alongside the A12 in Stratford St Andrew

Littering motorists have been criticised for their “thoughtless” behaviour after a dozen large bin bags of rubbish – including a pair of pants – were collected from the roadside.

Most read

Most commented

Topic pages