Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 13°C

min temp: 6°C

ESTD 1874 Search

Poll: Debate over whether Essex County Council should launch legal proceedings against Lord Hanningfield

06:30 09 July 2014

Lord Hanningfield leaving Chelmsford Crown Court where he stood trial for fiddling his House of Lords expenses.

Lord Hanningfield leaving Chelmsford Crown Court where he stood trial for fiddling his House of Lords expenses.

Councillors debate whether to pursue the former leader over allegedly extravagant spending at County Hall.

shares

The cost of pursuing Lord Hanningfield for allegedly wrongly claimed county council expenses could be more than £100,000 – and much higher if the authority lost.

The figure was revealed at a full meeting of Essex County Council yesterday.

Council leader David Finch said he was “damned if I do and damned if I don’t” when explaining his decision not to launch legal proceedings against the disgraced peer.

Mr Finch added: “I have mixed emotions and a heavy heart and am still angry about Lord Hanningfield and the expenses.”

Lord Hanningfield claimed or spent on corporate credit cards more than £288,000 between 2005 and 2010 when he was the leader at County Hall, and around £50,000 of that has been deemed to be illegitimate of extragavant spending which should be repaid.

A police investigation was dropped for having insufficient evidence, leaving the county council with a decision over whether or not to launch its own civil action to recoup the money.

Legal advice suggested the chances of success were low and it could cost more than £100,000 to bring the case, with the added risk the authority would have to pay Lord Hanningfield’s costs if he won.

Lord Hanningfield, real name Paul White, was jailed in 2011 in relation to wrongly claimed parliamentary expenses.

Conservative councillor Rodney Bass said: “We really do have to turn the leaf of the book and pass on.”

However Liberal Democrat group leader Mike Mackrory claimed there was a conflict of interest in Mr Finch making the decision as he had been councillor for finance during some of the period of spending.

His colleague Barry Aspinell went as far to say: “David Finch was implicated in this case, he was at times involved in the finances of this council when this procurement policy was invoked.

“Checks and balances were not in place and we need an inquiry to find out why.

“I am not suggesting for a second councillor Finch is a criminal or involved, but morally he should not vote on this.”

Several other councillors also called for a deeper inquiry as to who signed off Lord Hanningfield’s spending.

Many said they also sympathised with the tough decision Mr Finch had had to make.

Nigel Le Gresley, UKIP, said: “It is clear to pursue this would not be cost-effective. However the real issue has to be the interests of justice, the message we are sending out is the wrong message.

“Justice has to be seen to be done.”

At the end of the debate Mr Finch added he would be writing once more to Lord Hanningfield requesting repayment of the money, and also adding his name to calls for the peer’s title to be revoked – a suggestion made by UKIP councillor Kerry Smith.

shares
A large police cordon around the Tesco Extra store in Great Yarmouth.

Picture: James Bass

A Tesco Extra in Great Yarmouth was evacuated and searched by bomb disposal crews following a hoax call.

The White Horse pub in Sudbury is selling Zebra, Camel and Bison at its special steak night

While squirrel has been popping up on the menu of adventurous restaurants across Suffolk in recent months, it appears that the people of Sudbury have even more exotic tastes.

Fish and chip shop blaze in Sible Hedingham

Two people were treated for smoke inhalation after a fire at a fish and chip shop in Sible Hedingham.

Sam Smith

Tickets for Sam Smith’s highly-anticipated show at Thetford Forest sold out in less than three quarters of an hour today.

The MSC Oscar en route in the North Sea to its next port of call.

Hundreds of ship-spotters are expected to line the shore as the Port of Felixstowe welcomes the world’s largest container ship on Monday – just two months after the last holder of the title sailed into the harbour.

Tawny owl

Two men who were suspected by police of being responsible for the illegal trapping and killing of a tawny owl in west Suffolk will not be charged.

The Causeway in Hitcham

Hundreds of pounds in cash and jewellery were stolen from a home in Hitcham.

All Star Wrestling at the Corn Exchange

It might be ‘fake’ - but you can’t say it’s not fun.

Fire fighters tackle tractor blaze

Fire fighters were called to a tractor that was ablaze in a field in Pettistree.

Temporary chief constable Gareth Wilson and police and crime commissioner Tim Passmore

Suffolk Constabulary is pledging to support a national campaign aimed at promoting trust, integration and cohesion within communities.

Most read

Most commented

Topic pages