Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 22°C

min temp: 15°C

ESTD 1874 Search

Suffolk: Four men died as result of accident when steel cage collapsed, inquest finds

22:25 14 February 2014

Industrial accident at engineering company, Claxton at Runham, Great Yarmouth Scene where the four men died close to the boundary with the Vauxhall Holiday Park.

Industrial accident at engineering company, Claxton at Runham, Great Yarmouth Scene where the four men died close to the boundary with the Vauxhall Holiday Park.

Archant Norfolk Photographic © 2011

Four Suffolk men inside a steel cage which collapsed at a building site died as a result of an accident, an inquest has found.

shares

Loved ones said they will “never be able to come to terms with [their] devastating loss”, and firms are still facing the possibility of criminal prosecution by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE).

Jurors returned a unanimous verdict of accidental death on the fifth day of the inquest at Sprowston Manor, near Norwich, yesterday,

Daniel Hazelton, 30, and Adam Taylor, 28, both of Rickinghall, and Thomas Hazelton, 26, and Peter Johnson, 42, both of Stanton, near Bury St Edmunds, died on January 21, 2011.

The west Suffolk men had been constructing a steel cage to reinforce the concrete foundations of a high pressure test bay at Claxton Engineering in Great Yarmouth.

They were inside the cage, which was inside a 2metre-deep trench the length of a tennis court, and were fixing steel above their heads when it collapsed.

A total of 39 tonnes of steel and 330 tonnes of concrete would have been used in the completed structure.

Coroner Jacqueline Lake told jurors that they had heard some “complex and technical” evidence, but the inquest was fact-finding, not fault-finding, and they must not apportion blame.

She stressed it was not their job to decide if the company that designed the cage – Scott Wilson Group – had given enough detail in plans, if the right health and safety steps had been taken or if the men, who worked for Hazegood, had worked in line with an “adequate” method statement.

Earlier in the inquest it was heard that Encompass Project Management had not employed a construction design management (CDM) co-ordinator, who would have conducted site inspections, and some health and safety forms had not been correctly filled out. Several witnesses declined to answer questions which they feared could incriminate them.

After almost two hours of deliberation, the jury returned a verdict of accidental death for each man.

The medical cause of death was recorded as traumatic asphyxia, and in paperwork, jurors agreed the men “were working within a steel structure in an excavation at a construction site at Great Yarmouth”.

They added: “The steel structure collapsed, causing fatal injuries to all four men.”

Hannah Clarke, the solicitor representing the families of the deceased men, read a statement on their behalf.

It noted the men were “conscientious and skilled workers”, and expressed hope that the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) would prosecute “those responsible” so justice is done and lessons are learned.

The four men had worked for family firm Hazegood, which was sub-contracted by Encompass Project Management to lay the reinforced concrete foundations for the test bays.

Julia Kendrick, for Encompass Project Management, said Encompass had stopped taking on contracts in August 2012 and is not actively trading or involved in any sites.

She added directors had attempted to dissolve the company but were forbidden from doing so by the HSE.

The company had reviewed its procedures before then, the inquest heard.

Jon Elven, of the HSE, said: “The HSE will now review the evidence in light of the inquest and decide about whether further criminal proceedings are appropriate, and will announce any decision in relation to this in due course. Meanwhile our thoughts remain with the families of the deceased.”

The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) announced in February 2013 that it would bring no prosecutions after a lengthy investigation.

shares

1 comment

Can you spot him? Andrew Hawes in the camouflage gear he plans to use to catch people not clearing up after their dogs.

Hollywood actor Hugh Grant is apparently backing campaigners in a Suffolk town who plan to post photos of dog walkers on the internet if they fail to clean up after their pets.

The hoodie hides most of this man's face

The value of e-fits was defended last night as new figures reveal only one image released to the public in the past three years has resulted in an arrest.

The scene of an accident on the A1088 at Honington.

Suffolk’s police and crime commissioner Tim Passmore has insisted a new roads policing unit “will happen”, as a fatal road accident in Honington yesterday claimed the life of another driver.

Families enjoyed the warm weather at Georges Funday at Whitton United football ground on Saturday 1st August. The event will help raise funds towards a new wheelchair for George Woodward.

More than 1,000 people turned out at Whitton United Football Club in Ipswich on Saturday, to help raise funds for a child with a rare muscular condition.

Police are investigating

A woman in her 90s has had her handbag stolen from her car while it was parked at the Village Rise shops in Lowestoft on Saturday.

Officers detain a reveller in Ipswich town centre.

A clamp down on off-licences selling super-strength alcohol has been cited as a key reason behind a sharp drop in the number of people boozing and brawling in the streets of Ipswich.

Assistant librarian Stephen Dart is pictured in the Ancient Library at St Edmundsbury Cathedral in Bury.

It holds a wealth of religious books dating back hundreds of years, but the little-known Ancient Library at St Edmundsbury Cathedral also tells us about the local people of the time.

Caroline Shearer.

An anti-knife campaigner has branded the Government’s response to her petition calling for more education in schools about the dangers of weapons as a “total insult”.

Ipswich Magistrates Court in Elm Street.

A 60-year-old man is due to appear in court this morning charged with three driving offences.

Bury St Edmunds photographer Tom Murray with Cilla Black at a private viewing of his London exhibition of his Beatles images.

He has spent time with many celebrities during his career, but for Beatles photographer Tom Murray, Cilla Black had “true star quality”.

Most read

Most commented

Topic pages