Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 10°C

min temp: 3°C

ESTD 1874 Search

Suffolk: Report finds familiar failings in council’s use of spying law

11:56 28 March 2014

Report into Suffolk Coastal and Waveney

Report into Suffolk Coastal and Waveney's use of spying law

District bosses have pledged to redress failings uncovered during an inspection into its use of a surveillance tool nicknamed the ‘snooper’s charter’.

shares

In a review of covert activities at the council, the Government’s assistant surveillance commissioner criticised “significant faults” in the authorisation of a counter-terrorism law, used by local authorities to prevent or detect crime.

His Honour David Hodson said Suffolk Coastal District Council (SCDC) had failed to take on board recommendations made in the last inspection into its use of the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act (RIPA), despite acknowledging previous similar failings.

Under the Act, covert surveillance has been used by councils for benefit fraud investigations, environmental health investigations and anti-social behaviour issues.

In a joint review of SCDC and Waveney District Council (WDC), Mr Hodson offered some praise for the clarity and comprehension of the councils’ joint policy and procedures document. He found that the 15 investigating officers had been well trained to deal with any RIPA matter to come their way, and that further refresher training was planned for early this year.

While WDC had carried out surveillance under the Act just once since its last inspection in August 2010, SCDC had used RIPA powers four times since last reviewed in January 2011.

In that time, SCDC carried out surveillance on individuals in Felixstowe, Trimley St Martin, Saxmundham and Framlingham. In each instance, no action was taken against the individual because the “illegal activity ceased”.

On all four occasions, each authorising officer failed to state why they believed proposed surveillance activity was proportionate to the perceived problem. Mr Hodson observed a tendency for each officer to repeat the same phrase when authorising the use of surveillance - a defect identified in the 2011 report but not yet resolved.

In one authorisation, written cancellation of the surveillance was not done until almost a month after the surveillance had been completed.

Under Article 8 of the Human Rights Act 1998, any interference by a public authority into an individual’s privacy must be “lawful, necessary and proportionate”.

Mr Hodson found that the single authorisation at WDC also failed to explain why the surveillance was proportionate to the perceived problem, and that the officer did not state why he believed the proposed activity was necessary.

In his recommendations, Mr Hodson said: “Further work should be done in training to ensure that authorising officers are fully aware that they must explain fully why they believe that the proposed RIPA surveillance is both necessary and proportionate. A pro forma bald assertion is not sufficient.”

In conclusion, Mr Hodson acknowledged the professionalism and enthusiasm of staff but insisted that “significant faults” in every one of the councils’ five authorisations should not have been allowed to happen. “There really cannot be any excuse for these failings to be perpetuated,” he concluded.

Since 2012, local authority use of directed surveillance under RIPA has been limited to the investigation of crimes which carry a custodial sentence of six months or more, with the exception of offences relating to the underage sale of alcohol and tobacco.

In a report to the audit and governance committee, SCDC cabinet members Doreen Savage and Robert Whiting said that the recommendations made in Mr Hodson’s review have been accepted and implemented by the council.

shares

2 comments

  • anyone got any good comments about [ ORBIT HOUSING]?

    Report this comment

    TERENCE MANNING

    Friday, March 28, 2014

  • If the council cannot follow the rules when conducting an investigation then they probably would not be able to use any evidence they discovered. If the people involved don't understand that and the supervision is such that nobody bothers to stop it then there is the real question on why the councillors responsible for oversight don't stop their officers wasting public money in this way.

    Report this comment

    amsterdam81

    Friday, March 28, 2014

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Disused frontage at Severalls Hospital.

Trespassers on a derelict hospital site have been warned they will be prosecuted.

A large tree has smashed into electricity cables after heavy winds in Great Barton.

Strong winds early today have brought down trees and power lines around the county, causing disruption for morning travellers.

Shining Lights awards at West Suffolk Hospital, Bury St Edmunds. Left to right, Becki Nunn, Amber Rout, Kelly Bugg.

Healthcare staff who have helped to make a real difference to patients and their families over the last 12 months have been celebrated at the annual Shining Lights awards.

Latitude Festival, at the Henham Estate near Southwold

This year’s line-up of up-and-coming acts has been announced for Latitude’s Lake Stage – famous for hosting stars of the future on their rise to prominence.

Colchester General Hospital is preparing to open their new Radiotherapy Centre.

A massive jobs fair is being held by the trust running Colchester’s hospitals in a bid to tackle a shortage of nurses.

The Stagecoach Spectacular at The Apex in Bury.

More than 100 young people got the chance to put on a show at a professional concert hall in Bury St Edmunds.

Concerns over impact on nearby Leiston Abbey

Proposals to redevelop a no-longer-profitable holiday park with housing are set to go ahead, despite objections from community leaders.

Kesgrave Hall School in 1988

More than 20 ex-pupils of a former Suffolk school have made allegations of physical and sexual abuse, Suffolk Constabulary has said.

Ipswich Crown Court

A Suffolk nightclub owner who shoved a man in the chest causing him to fall backwards and hit his head on the pavement has been warned he is facing a jail sentence after admitting manslaughter.

Ipswich Academy.

A shadow of doubt has been cast over the capability of the new sponsor of a struggling academy in Ipswich.

Most read

Most commented

Topic pages