max temp: 19°C

min temp: 17°C


Witham MP Priti Patel slams case of immigrant in constituency who has avoided deportation through multiple appeals

PUBLISHED: 09:24 23 October 2013 | UPDATED: 09:24 23 October 2013

Priti Patel

Priti Patel

Archant © 2006

Major reform to the UK’s immigration system is needed to stop those without the right to remain in the country from outstaying their welcome, an Essex MP has warned.

During a debate in Parliament yesterday Witham’s Priti Patel raised a case of a Filipino woman in her constituency who had been in the UK since 2006 and had avoided deportation by lodging multiple applications and appeals.

The Conservative MP said that this undermined public confidence in the immigration system and blamed the previous administration for a failure to act, urging the government to introduce new controls.

The Immigration Bill, which started its second reading in the House of Commons, aims to reform the appeal system and close legislative gaps within the European Convention on Human Rights.

The woman from the Philippines has been in the UK since 2006, arriving on a 48-month permit to work in a care home and her husband, family and children had come over and gone to local schools, Ms Patel said.

Despite the rejection of an appeal to remain in the UK the family lodged a further application on human rights grounds in January, which was refused in June, she added.

“The case is now going on and on,” Ms Patel said. “In July, they lodged another appeal, which is still pending. If that appeal is rejected, the family may undertake another appeal and prolong the process even more. Surely that cannot be right?”.

She also highlighted a family from Nigeria who were informed that they should leave the UK two years ago, but embarked on a series of applications and appeals.

Ms Patel said: “Such actions are all about delay and prolonging the process for people who have no right whatever to remain in the country. That undermines public confidence in the immigration system. A stop must be put to repeated applications and appeals.”

During the Westminster Hall debate Ms Patel blamed the previous government for leaving too many cases unresolved.

She also called for further reforms to remove foreign criminals, prisoners and terrorists and reforms to human rights laws.

But she said the government needed to ensure that the UK had an immigration system that “let in wealth creators, entrepreneurs and people who will make a positive contribution to this country, while preventing from coming in, and removing, those who should not be here.”

She told Parliament; “In the run-up to the last general election and during the election in 2010, it was the number one issue raised with me in my constituency—the issue on which my constituents were pressing for action. That is not surprising, because it is a rural constituency in the east of England, so it has many issues with seasonal agricultural workers and migrants coming in.

“My constituents wanted, and are eager to see, a wide range of effective reforms and policies put in place to keep our borders secure and the public safe.”

Answering the debate, immigration minister Mark Harper said: “I fundamentally believe that we should offer asylum to those who are genuinely fleeing persecution, but if the system is to work and to command public confidence, the flip side is that those who we find do not need our protection—and where an independent judge agrees that they do not need our protection—should return to their country of origin.

“We should not have to spend thousands and thousands of pounds of taxpayers’ money detaining those people and enforcing their removal. Everyone who abuses our system in such a way is damaging the interests of genuine refugees, to whom I want Britain to give a warm welcome and to enable them to rebuild their lives.”


  • That's right blame it all on Labour !, what exactly has your party done about it in the last 3 and a half years ?, and just to remind people it was the tories who signed us up to the (UNEconomic) European Community !, with all the rights of immigration from all the EU countries !

    Report this comment


    Wednesday, October 23, 2013

  • Typical Tory Tosh - blame everyone else!

    Report this comment


    Wednesday, October 23, 2013

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

What a phenomenal concert. From the performance, the outfits and the atmosphere, Little Mix at Newmarket Nights on Friday, June 23, were fantastic.

Lavinia Akyurt, 42, of Hartlepool at the time of the offences, now of Southsea, Hampshire, smuggled cigarettes and tobacco into the UK through London Stansted, Durham Tees Valley, and Gatwick airports.

Former Colchester Academy student Kyle Collier has been put in a medically induced coma after a fatal two-car collision in Thorrington in north-east Essex earlier this week.

The cult game show was the top UK trend on Twitter on Friday night after getting its official revival. What did you make of the return?

Suffolk suppliers of insulation used in the £8.6million refurbishment of Grenfell Tower say it will no longer be supplied for cladding on high-rise buildings.

A man who returned to his home in Stowmarket last night was pinned to the ground by robbers using cable ties before cash and jewellery were stolen.

A man chased by police through Ipswich this afternoon has been taken to hospital after a crash involving an unmarked police car.

Most read

Eating Out in the Broads


Click here to view
the Eating Out


Visit the Broads


Click here to view
the Visit the Broads


Most commented

Show Job Lists

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to the following newsletters:

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter
MyDate24 MyPhotos24