UK: Mixed views on ‘forward guidance’ as Bank of England again leaves monetary policy on hold

The Bank of England.

The Bank of England. - Credit: PA

The Bank of England has kept interest rates at their record low, but gathering signs of economic cheer have cast doubt over governor Mark Carney’s pledge to leave the cost of borrowing for another three years.

Policymakers also held back from any more recovery-boosting measures under the bank’s £375billion quantitative easing (QE) drive after recent reports have suggested the UK economy is startomg to fire on all cylinders.

Today’s decision is the first since the bank launched its new forward guidance policy, vowing to keep interest rates at their historic low of 0.5% until the unemployment rate falls to 7%.

But it has so far failed to have the desired effect on the City, with a series of caveats to the announcement last month prompting market expectations to be brought forward rather than pushed back.

While the bank has implied rates will stay on hold until at least 2016, markets are predicting an increase in the first quarter of 2015.

A raft of exceptionally strong sector surveys this week has added to fears that rates may rise sooner than the bank’s new policy suggests.

There was no accompanying statement to the decision, despite speculation the bank might have sought to shore up its forward guidance policy once more to win over City sceptics.

Most Read

Mr Carney used his first public speech in Nottingham last week to deliver the blunt message that rates will stay low for at least another three years.

Since then, a slew of highly positive figures from all sectors of the economy have only strengthened the market’s views.

Closely watched Markit/CIPS purchasing managers’ index (PMI) readings suggested the powerhouse services sector accelerated at its fastest pace for more than six years in August.

This followed similarly strong readings from the manufacturing and construction sectors, with a composite survey combining all three hitting another record high in August.

The data fuelled hopes that third-quarter growth can beat expansion of 0.7% in the April to June quarter, with Markit suggesting growth of as much as 1.3%.

James Knightley, economist at ING Bank, said with the housing market potentially heading for another boom and inflation already well above the 2% target, one or more of the bank’s so-called knockouts could be triggered, breaking the rates pledge.

“As such, markets ? ourselves included ? suspect that the first rate hike is more likely to come in early to mid 2015,” he said.

But some experts gave Mr Carney and his forward guidance strategy a vote of confidence.

Alan Clarke, a director at Scotiabank, said: “The bank is not going to be whipped around by short-term swings in the market. Higher market interest rates are probably an irritation, but not a game changer at this point.”

He added: “Based on the fact that the vast majority of economists still expect unchanged rates for around two years, forward guidance has been a runaway success.”

Vicky Redwood at consultancy Capital Economics also pointed out that the recovery momentum does not necessarily mean rates will rise sooner than expected.

Signs of slowing growth in employment across the main sectors of the economy suggest firms are meeting the upsurge in demand more through working existing employees harder than by taking on extra workers.

This supports the Monetary Policy Committee’s view that growth can be driven by productivity rather than employment gains, she said.

Mr Carney has also hinted at the potential for more QE if market rate expectations feed through into broader financial conditions or hamper the recovery.

This has sparked speculation over the bank’s plans for more asset purchases, although Mr Carney has made it clear that the actual Bank rate is more important than market expectations to most Britons.

He recently pointed out that interest rates on 70% of loans to households and 50% of those to businesses were linked to the Bank rate rather than the market.

But fixed-rate mortgages are linked to market rate expectations and it is thought that borrowers could soon start to see a rise in the cost of these loans as swap rates increase.